Academic Peer Review Strategies
Consultant shares tips on 'How to Give (and Receive) Feedback'
Peer review is foundational to our profession as scholars. But does anyone ever teach us how to provide effective peer review to our colleagues? And how do we interpret the mixed bag of peer review feedback that we sometimes receive on our book manuscripts, journal articles, and funding proposals?
On Dec. 13, 2024, Janet Salmons, Ph.D. led a Zoom session for the Corridor highlighting the importance of peer review, how to give constructive feedback to your colleagues, and how to deal with negative or conflicting reviews that you may receive. This session was inspired by her article, “When Peer Review Goes Right” (2022) in the Sage Research Methods Community.
The recording, slides, and resources from the workshop are available on the SU Office of Research Trainings and Presentations site. [Link to additional resources in the CNY Humanities Corridor post...]